Mr Anastasiades and Mr Malas, backed by the left-wing Akel party, will now contest the run-off vote.
BBC: Cyprus election: Anastasiades and Malas go to run-off
2.
For many observers, the key lies with Demetris Christofias, leader of the Greek-Cypriot communist party Akel which governs in coalition with Mr Papadopoulos.
ECONOMIST: Cyprus
3.
Akel has historically taken a moderate line on the island's future, and Turkish doves were dismayed by its refusal to endorse the plan.