"We've got banana cream, raisin cream, pumpkin, mincemeat and pecan, " says the 69-year-old retired nurse.

WSJ: Moveable Feast: This Cycling Tour Has Bikers on a Culinary Crusade

Arrive before lunch to get the best selection, which also includes peanut butter, Snickers and banana cream.

BBC: Tastes of the American pie revolution

We picked out a range of flavors, including the "grasshopper" (chocolate cake filled with fudge and topped with mint cream-cheese frosting, cake crumbs, chocolate chips and a buttercream rosette) and the "Elvis" (vanilla cake filled and frosted with banana-cream-cheese icing, with a swirl of peanut butter and peanut-butter chips).

WSJ: Testing Mail-Order Cupcakes