But two judges dismissed the appealagainst the finding on liability.
BBC: Hampshire PC to keep almost ?5,000 damages for cut thumb
2.
But, following an appeal by the club against that finding to the Scottish Football Assocation, the decision to sack him was reinstated.
BBC: Drug-accused Thomas wins appeal
3.
Charles Hattersley, Mrs Wilkin-Shaw's solicitor, said while she was disappointed with the Appeal Court's ruling, she also felt vindicated at the judge's finding of negligence against Miss Timms.