Even before the invention of the electric light bulb, the author produced a remarkable work of speculative fiction.

But Peter Wood, an anthropologist, the author of "diversity: the Invention of a Concept" and a critic of the Grutter decision, argues that the educational value of racial diversity is problematic.

These findings, we think, show this photograph to be an original work of art, the product of plaintiff's intellectual invention, of which plaintiff is the author.